|
Liturgical Time
Bombs
in Vatican II: Excerpts
The Destruction of Catholic
Faith
Through Changes in Catholic
Worship
by
Michael Davies
TAN
BOOKS
Published
on the Web with
Permission of the Author.
A Pastoral Disaster
The effects of the reforms are now manifest for everyone to see-----and
the most evident of these effects has been a decline in Mass
attendance,
which has worsened in extent the more radical the reforms have been. It
fell from 41 per cent of the population in France attending Mass in
1964
to 8 per cent in 2002-----and
where young people are concerned, only 2% now assist at Mass. [NOTE
4] It would certainly be impossible to prove that every
Catholic
who has ceased attending Mass has done so because he dislikes the
liturgical
reforms. Progressive liturgists claim that many Catholics do not go
because
they would actually like the reforms to be more radical! What any
sociologist
could certainly have pointed out is that to disrupt completely the
established
customs of any community in so drastic and abrupt a manner,
particularly
a community in which stability had always been so important a
characteristic,
must certainly loosen the bonds which hold its members together.
Pastorally, the reform has been
a fiasco,
a disaster. What sort of success can be attributed to pastoral measures
which are followed by a large proportion of the flock-----which
they are intended to help-----leaving
the sheepfold for new pastures? All this has been done in the interests
of a spurious form of ecumenism which has not brought true religious
unity
as much as one step nearer. "All these changes have but one
justification,"
remarked Archbishop Lefebvre, "an aberrant senseless ecumenism that
will
not attract a single Protestant to the Faith, but will cause countless
Catholics to lose it, and will instill total confusion into the minds
of
many more, who will no longer know what is true and what is false." [World
Trends, May 1974.] The complete accuracy of Archbishop
Lefebvre's
assessment of the nature and effects of the reform is made clear in an
article written by a young and outspoken Italian prelate, Monsignor
Domenico
Celada. His remarks appeared in the Italian journal lo Specchio
on May 16,1969. Since that day the situation he described has worsened-----year,
after year, after year:
The
gradual destruction
of the liturgy is a sad fact already well known. Within less than five
years, the thousand year old structure of Divine worship which
throughout
the centuries has been known as the Opus Dei has been
dismantled.
The beginning was the abolition of Latin, perpetrated in a fraudulent
manner.
The Council had in fact clearly laid down that "The use of the Latin
language
is to be preserved," while permitting the use of the vernacular in
certain
places, in certain cases, and in certain parts of the rite. By
contrast,
and in defiance of the authority of the Council, Latin has been
suppressed
practically everywhere, at all times, and in all parts of the
rite.
The Church's language has been abandoned, even at international
liturgical
functions. The universality of the Church is today claimed to be
stressed
by the use, on such occasions, of as many different languages as
possible.
The result is that-----unless these
are
used simultaneously-----all those
parts
of the rite which are not in one's own language become
incomprehensible.
It is Pentecost in reverse: while at Jerusalem the people "ex omni
natione,
quae sub caelo est" ["from every nation under Heaven"] understood
the
words of the Apostles, who were speaking but one language, so today,
when
all the different languages are spoken, nobody can understand anything.
Instead of Pentecost, we should rather speak of Babel. We have seen,
during
these past years, the abolition of those sublime gestures of devotion
and
piety, such as Signs of the Cross, kissing of the altar which
symbolizes
Christ, genuflections, etc., gestures which the secretary of the
congregation
responsible for liturgical reform, Father Annibale Bugnini, has dared
publicly
to describe as "anachronisms" and "wearisome externals." Instead, a
puerile
form of rite has been imposed, noisy, uncouth and extremely boring. And
hypocritically, no notice has been taken of the disturbance and disgust
of the faithful . . . Resounding success has been claimed for it
because
a proportion of the faithful has been trained to repeat mechanically a
succession of phrases which through repetition have already lost their
effect. We have witnessed with horror the introduction into our
churches
of hideous parodies of the sacred texts, of tunes and instruments more
suited to the tavern. And the instigator and persistent advocate of
these
so-called "youth masses" is none other than Father Annibale Bugnini. It
is here recalled that he insisted on continuing . . . the "yea, yea
Masses"
in Rome, and got his way despite the protest of Rome's Vicar General,
Cardinal
Dell'Acqua. During the pontificate of John XXIII, Bugnini had been
expelled
from the Lateran University where he was a teacher of liturgy precisely
because he held such ideas-----only to
become, later, secretary of the congregation dealing with liturgical
reform.
4. La
Croix, December 24 and 25, 2002. The same report reveals the alarming
facts
that while in 1962, 52% of priests in France were under 50 years of
age,
in 2000 it was only 11%. In 1960, 595 priests were ordained; in 2000
the
figure was 142.
HOME------------------- HOLY
EUCHARIST
www.catholictradition.org/Eucharist/v2-bombs11.htm
|